DALLAS’ PRESCOTT RISES TO NO. 1 OVERALL, KANSAS CITY’S MAHOMES WINS WEEK 12 IN UPDATED NFL QUARTERBACK RANKINGS: The Cowboys’ Dak Prescott is No. 1 overall for the first time this season in the Miami Herald’s NFL quarterback rankings through Week 12. Prescott jumps two spots to the top on the wing of a 45.55-point game that ranked second for the week — less than one point behind the winning Week 12 total for the Chiefs’ Patrick Mahomes. Miami’s Tua Tagovailoa dips from No. 1 to second in the overall rankings but it’s a virtual tie at the top, with Tagovailoa less than two points behind.
Our ratings system is cumulative not percentile-based, rewarding players who are consistently productive and avoid injury or benching. Because it is cumulative, players on a bye take a temporary hit that evens out over the course of a season. This is the 26th year for the Herald’s Passer Success System (PASS) rankings, which began in 1998 with Steve Young the inaugural season champion.
Our ratings formula factors accuracy, passing yardage, touchdown/interception ratio and team result. They are passer ratings per se and do not include a QB’s running statistics. The updated 2023 top 20 entering Week 13:
Rk LW Player, Team W12 Season
1. 3. Dak Prescott, DAL 45.55 385.75
2. 1. Tua Tagovailoa, MIA 26.15 383.85
3. 2. Josh Allen, BUF 26.95 380.70
4. 6. Patrick Mahomes, KC 45.90 370.90
5. 5. Jared Goff, DET 36.60 368.75
6. 4. Sam Howell, WAS 24.00 361.90
7. 7. Brock Purdy, SF 27.45 345.55
8. 1.0 C.J. Stroud, HOU 37.20 342.30
9. 8. Jalen Hurts, PHI 26.00 334.85
10. 9. Justin Herbert, LAC 24.85 332.25
11. 11. Lamar Jackson, BAL 20.85 321.90
12. 14. Trevor Lawrence, JAC 31.20 320.30
13. 15. Russell Wilson, DEN 18.70 305.95
14. 12. Kirk Cousins, MIN DNP 296.55
15. 16. Baker Mayfield, TB 22.95 291.40
16. 13. Joe Burrow, CIN DNP 290.45
17. 17. Geno Smith, SEA 15.00 282.05
18. 18. Derek Carr, NO 22.20 281.75
19. 20. Jordan Love, GB 39.40 259.95
20. 19. Joshua Dobbs, ARI-MIN 12.25 254.05
21. 22. Matthew Stafford, LAR 42.45 235.45
Week 12 best: Mahomes, KC, 45.90 (27-34, 298, 2-0 in win). Week 12 worst (min. 10 attempts): Mac Jones, NE, 1.45 (12-21, 89, 0-2 in loss). Bubble: Matthew Stafford, LAR, 235.45. Dropouts: None.
Record-best week: Ben Roethlisberger, PIT, 80.10 (2014). Record-worst week: Tim Hasselbeck, WAS, minus-23.20 (2003). Season-record point total: Peyton Manning, DEN, 714.85 (2013).
